Server Side Template Injection

Payloads and bypasses for web application security

Template injection allows an attacker to include template code into an existing (or not) template. A template engine makes designing HTML pages easier by using static template files which at runtime replaces variables/placeholders with actual values in the HTML pages.

Summary#

Tools#

  • Hackmanit/TInjA - An efficient SSTI + CSTI scanner which utilizes novel polyglots
  tinja url -u "http://example.com/?name=Kirlia" -H "Authentication: Bearer ey..."
  tinja url -u "http://example.com/" -d "username=Kirlia"  -c "PHPSESSID=ABC123..."
  • epinna/tplmap - Server-Side Template Injection and Code Injection Detection and Exploitation Tool
  python2.7 ./tplmap.py -u 'http://www.target.com/page?name=John*' --os-shell
  python2.7 ./tplmap.py -u "http://192.168.56.101:3000/ti?user=*&comment=supercomment&link"
  python2.7 ./tplmap.py -u "http://192.168.56.101:3000/ti?user=InjectHere*&comment=A&link" --level 5 -e jade
  python3 ./sstimap.py -u 'https://example.com/page?name=John' -s
  python3 ./sstimap.py -i -u 'https://example.com/page?name=Vulnerable*&message=My_message' -l 5 -e jade
  python3 ./sstimap.py -i -A -m POST -l 5 -H 'Authorization: Basic bG9naW46c2VjcmV0X3Bhc3N3b3Jk'

Methodology#

Detection and Exploitation Techniques#

Original research:

Rendered#

Rendered technique workflow
Rendered technique workflow

Applicability: detection, exploitation

When the rendered template is displayed to the attacker, Rendered technique can be used to include the results of the injected code on the page.

Error-Based#

Error-Based technique workflow
Error-Based technique workflow

Applicability: detection, exploitation

When the errors are verbosely displayed to the attacker, Error-Based technique can be used to trigger the error message containing the results of the injected code.

Boolean-Based#

Boolean-Based technique workflow
Boolean-Based technique workflow

Applicability: detection, blind exploitation, blind data exfiltration

Boolean-Based technique can be used to conditionally trigger an error to indicate success or failure of the injected code.

Time-Based#

Time-Based technique workflow
Time-Based technique workflow

Applicability: limited detection, blind exploitation, blind data exfiltration

Time-Based technique can be used to conditionally trigger the delay to indicate success or failure of the injected code.

Triggering the delay often requires guessing payloads for code evaluation or OS command execution.

Out of Bounds#

Applicability: limited detection, exploitation

Out of Bounds technique can be used to expose results of the injected code through other channels (e.g. by connecting to an attacker-controlled server).

This technique often requires guessing payloads for code evaluation or OS command execution.

Polyglot-Based#

Polyglot-Based technique workflow
Polyglot-Based technique workflow

Applicability: detection

Polyglot-Based technique can be used to quickly determine the template engine by checking how it transforms different payloads.

Universal Detection Payloads#

Polyglot to trigger an error in presence of SSTI vulnerability:

${{<%[%'"}}%\.

Common tags to test for SSTI with code evaluation:

{{ ... }}
${ ... }
#{ ... }
<%= ... %>
{ ... }
{{= ... }}
{= ... }
\n= ... \n
*{ ... }
@{ ... }
@( ... )

Rendered SSTI can be checked by using mathematical expressions inside the tags:

7 * 7

Error-Based SSTI can be checked by using this payload inside the tags:

(1/0).zxy.zxy

If the error caused by that payload is displayed verbosely, it can be checked to guess the language used for code evaluation:

ErrorLanguage
ZeroDivisionErrorPython
java.lang.ArithmeticExceptionJava
ReferenceErrorNodeJS
TypeErrorNodeJS
Division by zeroPHP
DivisionByZeroErrorPHP
divided by 0Ruby
Arithmetic operation failedFreemarker (Java)

To test for blind injections using Boolean-Based technique, the attacker can test pairs of similar payloads wrapped in tags, where one payload evaluates mathematical expression, while the other triggers syntax error:

testokerror
1(3*4/2)3*)2(/4
2((7*8)/(2*4))7)(*)8)(2/(*4

Using at least two pairs of payloads avoids false positives caused by external interference.

Manual Detection and Exploitation#

Identify the Vulnerable Input Field#

The attacker first locates an input field, URL parameter, or any user-controllable part of the application that is passed into a server-side template without proper sanitization or escaping.

For example, the attacker might identify a web form, search bar, or template preview functionality that seems to return results based on dynamic user input.

TIP: Generated PDF files, invoices and emails usually use a template.

Inject Template Syntax#

The attacker tests the identified input field by injecting template syntax specific to the template engine in use. Different web frameworks use different template engines (e.g., Jinja2 for Python, Twig for PHP, or FreeMarker for Java).

Common template expressions:

  • {{7*7}} for Jinja2 (Python).
  • #{7*7} for Thymeleaf (Java).

Find more template expressions in the page dedicated to the technology (PHP, Python, etc).

SSTI cheatsheet workflow
SSTI cheatsheet workflow

In most cases, this polyglot payload will trigger an error in presence of a SSTI vulnerability:

${{<%[%'"}}%\.

The Hackmanit/Template Injection Table is an interactive table containing the most efficient template injection polyglots along with the expected responses of the 44 most important template engines.

Enumerate the Template Engine#

Based on the successful response, the attacker determines which template engine is being used. This step is critical because different template engines have different syntax, features, and potential for exploitation. The attacker may try different payloads to see which one executes, thereby identifying the engine.

  • Python: Django, Jinja2, Mako, …
  • Java: Freemarker, Jinjava, Velocity, …
  • Ruby: ERB, Slim, …

The post “template-engines-injection-101” from @0xAwali summarize the syntax and detection method for most of the template engines for JavaScript, Python, Ruby, Java and PHP and how to differentiate between engines that use the same syntax.

Escalate to Code Execution#

Once the template engine is identified, the attacker injects more complex expressions, aiming to execute server-side commands or arbitrary code.

Labs#

References#